Why I'm Closing Erin's Faces (& What's Next)

I've been trying to figure out what to write about for the last month. How to write it - how to say how I'm feeling. So I'll tell you a story that helped me make my decision on closing Erin's Faces.  

I had called a dear friend who's a fellow beauty brand founder and talked with her as I was wrestling with my decision of "to close or not to close". Something she said struck a chord with me - it was to the effect of, "You've worked so hard, put in so much time, and I hate to think that it would just be over."  

I thought back to when I started Erin's Faces.  I was living in Queens and had been a musical theatre performer. Since I was 22 I had worked in makeup to pay my bills and every so often I'd book a show, clear out of town for a few months, sing, dance and share stories with an audience. And so at 33, I was doing all of this and the seed for Erin's Faces was planted, so I started the company but kept auditioning.  

Erin's Faces began to grow and certain point I couldn't audition anymore - I had to make a choice.  EF was too small to leave in someone else's hands, as I was a one man band at that point. But I believed in it and I knew if I left it to do a show I wouldn't be able to keep it going very easily. And so I stopped auditioning and even paused my union status in the stage actors union. I chose Erin's Faces.  Even though I had put in so much work, so much time into performing, so much money into training. Even though I loved theatre and singing and storytelling, I stopped doing it because I was called to do something different. And so I walked away from it.

A realization came over me: "what if I had stayed in theatre?  Erin's Faces would have never existed as it does today. I wouldn't have the community, the amount of products, the staff, the people I've met all over the country, the education sessions I've led, the lessons I've learned, the goodness we've shared with our customers - none of it would have existed if I stayed where I was." And that's when I knew what my decision needed to be.  

I'm being called to do something different.  And it won't get a chance to exist if I don't step away from Erin's Faces. Which brings tears to my eyes as I type because I love what we've built - and let me be clear - WE built this together. I couldn't have done it by myself - not a chance. And I love what we made -  the products are my favorite products -  but most of all I love US - I love the people, the connections. It's YOU.  

And I'm hoping to build on that and create even more connections with even more people in this next phase. It feels right, it feels exciting, and I have so many ideas. Coaching entrepreneurs, working with corporations about company culture/empathy in the workplace, shining a light on small businesses, teaching courses about building your company - I want to do all of it.  

Some piece of Erin's Faces will continue to exist - formulas will be shared with other folks, either on a small or large scale, that remains to be seen - but the trust that we've built together - that isn't going to go away. I'm still here and will still be on social media and I hope that we can stay in one another's lives.  

In the days since closing I've received some of the kindest messages about the good that we've done at Erin's Faces - telling people they're beautiful just as they are, that nothing in your appearance needs to be fixed or altered in order to "fit", that we're all valuable and deserve to be seen and heard. I want to do more of that. I want to lift more people up. I hope you'll stay with me as I do because I truly believe this is just the beginning.  xo


15 comments


  • Suzanne Rainey

    Hi Beautiful Erin!
    I am a relative of Kathy & Becky Hostler. Becky highly recommended your products. Sorry to see you go but admire your positive spirit! I am certain others will now benefit from whatever you endeavor to do.
    Sincerely, Suzanne


  • Audra Schumacher

    Erin, you’re such a beautiful person inside and out! I’m grateful for all you’ve done for so many people. I’m glad you are moving in a direction in your life that will fulfill you in a new and exciting way. You always will be able to take what you learned, the people who grew with you to the next steps in your life. We only have one life to live. Live it well! All the best to you! Hugs, Audra


  • Mim

    Much much Love and Success Wishes to you. I’ve especially L💝VED that you were right down the street from me 🥰

    Thank you 🫂🥰🥰💞💜💜💞🫂🥰💜☀️☀️☀️


  • Bets

    You have so much to give in some many ways, my friend! I look forward to seeing where you go from here!!


  • E Saville

    I went searching for a good quality makeup brand and found Erin’s faces. I couldn’t believe the name- I had to try your products! I really love everything I’ve tried! I wear very little makeup and your products were just what I needed when I needed them. Thank you so much, your makeup was a God-send and I’m thankful I was able to have this experience.

    Thanks, Erin ❤️


Leave a comment

Please note, comments must be approved before they are published

This site is protected by hCaptcha and the hCaptcha Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.